Does a trier of fact have to consider standard of care before determining whether there has been a breach of the standard or otherwise?

Ontario, Canada


The following excerpt is from Armstrong v. Royal Victoria Hospital, 2019 ONCA 963 (CanLII):

I agree with my colleague, at paras. 59 to 63, that typically, it makes sense for the trier of fact to consider causation only after finding a breach of the standard of care: see, for example, Bafaro v. Dowd, 2010 ONCA 188, 260 O.A.C. 70, at paras. 35-36. Determining standard of care before causation ensures that the trial judge does not wrongly reason backwards from the fact of the injury to determine that the standard of care has been breached. However, I also agree with my colleague’s observation that at times the court will need to determine “what happened” (that is, the factual cause of the plaintiff’s injury) in order to resolve whether the standard of care has been breached. Determining factual (and not “but-for”) causation is sometimes necessary before a conclusion can be reached on whether there has been a breach of the standard of care.

Other Questions


What is the test for determining whether a risk is material and whether there has been a breach of the duty of disclosure? (Ontario, Canada)
What factors are considered to be determinative in determining whether a person will be successful in their claim to be a property owner? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the standard for determining whether a party has breached a duty of care and is negligent? (Ontario, Canada)
What facts must be considered in determining whether a child has involuntarily withdrawn from parental control? (Ontario, Canada)
What factors will the court consider in determining whether to consolidate two separate actions at the same time? (Ontario, Canada)
What factors will the court consider in determining whether to award damages to a plaintiff in a motor vehicle accident in a different county? (Ontario, Canada)
What factors are considered in determining whether a person with severe depression should be found dead? (Ontario, Canada)
What factors must be considered in determining whether to enforce a settlement under Rule 49.09? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the test for determining whether a defendant’s jurisdiction has to be determined by the Court of Appeal? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the standard of review for determining whether a person has capacity to refuse treatment? (Ontario, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.