What is the crumbling skull rule?

New Brunswick, Canada


The following excerpt is from Gerd'son v. Howe, 2006 NBQB 78 (CanLII):

In the case of Athey v. Leonati 1996 CanLII 183 (SCC), [1996] 3 S.C.R. 458 Justice Major discussed the crumbling skull rule at pages 473 - 4 as follows: The so-called “crumbling skull" rule simply recognizes that the pre-existing condition was inherent in the plaintiff's “original position". The defendant need not put the plaintiff in a position better than his or her original position. The defendant is liable for the injuries caused, even if they are extreme, but need not compensate the plaintiff for any debilitating effects of the pre-existing condition which the plaintiff would have experienced anyway. The defendant is liable for the additional damage but not the pre-existing damage... Likewise, if there is a measurable risk that the pre-existing condition would have detrimentally affected the plaintiff in the future, regardless of the defendant's negligence, then this can be taken into account in reducing the overall award... This is consistent with the general rule that the plaintiff must be returned to the position he would have been in, with all of its attendant risks and shortcomings, and not a better position. [Emphasis in original]

Other Questions


What is the evidentiary test for applying Rule 23 of the Rules of Civil Procedure? (New Brunswick, Canada)
What is the impact of the “crumbling skull” argument? (New Brunswick, Canada)
What common law recognizes what came to be known as the "indoor management rule"? (New Brunswick, Canada)
What is the test for an order under section 265.6 of the Rules of Civil Procedure? (New Brunswick, Canada)
What is the meaning of a specific fund under the Rules of Civil Procedure? (New Brunswick, Canada)
What is the test for ordering separate trials under rule 47.03? (New Brunswick, Canada)
What is the equal authenticity rule on collective agreements between English and French? (New Brunswick, Canada)
Is Rule 22 sufficient to prevent a matter from proceeding to trial? (New Brunswick, Canada)
What is the scope of a motion under Rule 23.01(1)(a)? (New Brunswick, Canada)
Is there an invariable rule that a cell phone will connect to the closest tower to it? (New Brunswick, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.