Is a bankrupt a fiduciary position?

Alberta, Canada


The following excerpt is from R. v. Yaremkevich, 2002 ABPC 174 (CanLII):

My review of the law is that the law does not support a view that the bankrupt occupies a position of trust. The employer/employee relationship is somewhat similar to the position of a bankrupt. While the former relationship meets the classic characteristics of fiduciary relationship set out in Frame v. Smith, the latter does not. When the three characteristics of Frame v. Smith are applied to the bankrupt’s position, it is questionable that this position meets the characteristics. The bankrupt does not have power or a discretion to exercise it; rather, the bankrupt has knowledge about his affairs and specific responsibilities under the Act. Secondly, the bankrupt cannot unilaterally exercise the power or discretion; rather, the bankrupt can choose to be less than candid with the trustees or creditors. Thirdly, while the creditors and trustee are in a vulnerable position because of the bankrupt’s candour or lack of candour, this is not the type of vulnerability which means they are “peculiarly vulnerable or at the mercy of the bankrupt”. Certainly, a trustee under the Act would be in a fiduciary position. (2) Is jail required for abusing a position of trust ?

Other Questions


Can a bankruptcy judge grant a judgment against a bankrupt who has been declared bankrupt? (Alberta, Canada)
Does a punitive damages claim by a bankrupt pass to the trustee as property of the bankrupt? (Alberta, Canada)
Can a fiduciary or passive trustee of an estate be sued for loss of funds by a broker who had no knowledge of the breach of fiduciaries duties? (Alberta, Canada)
What is the test for a fiduciary relationship where the beneficiary is a beneficiary of the fiduciaries' trust? (Alberta, Canada)
Can an employee who has served as an employee of a bankrupt subsidiary of a corporation for more than a decade be held liable for breach of contract by that bankrupt subsidiary? (Alberta, Canada)
What are the duties of a doctor in the fiduciary relationship with a patient? (Alberta, Canada)
What is the position of the accused in the context of medical marijuana use? (Alberta, Canada)
Does the analysis of the second step of analysis for a breach of a fiduciary duty, or is it likely to be negative or negative? (Alberta, Canada)
Is there a fiduciary obligation on a relationship? (Alberta, Canada)
Can a trustee in bankruptcy make use of provincial legislation in gathering in the assets of a bankrupt? (Alberta, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.