Does a part performance claim an insurable interest in a property where the tenant has made substantial improvements to the property?

Alberta, Canada


The following excerpt is from Toombs v. Mueller, 1974 CanLII 263 (AB QB):

On the other hand, in Roberts v. Colwell, supra, the plaintiff had a lease of a house. He claimed that the owner had entered into an agreement to sell it to him. As acts of part performance he pointed to entry into possession of the land surrounding the house, and improvements he had made and money he had spent on the premises. Baxter J. held that these acts were not unequivocally referable to the alleged agreement for sale, that there was no visible difference between the occupancy under the lease and that under the alleged agreement, and that the improvements were such as a tenant would make. The improvements described in the judgment were of a very slight nature. By contrast, the owner made substantial improvements upon the property, paid the taxes and kept up the insurance. (In respect of the latter, Baxter J. observed, at p. 461: "Evidently the (plaintiff) did not consider that his alleged purchase gave him an insurable interest in the property.")

Other Questions


Is there any requirement that an insurer honour a collision claim from its own insured before it can consider a subrogated claim from the other insurer? (Alberta, Canada)
What are the circumstances in which execution/enforcement creditors obtained interest in the property of one spouse's property after the other spouse commenced an action for division of matrimonial property? (Alberta, Canada)
How have courts dealt with a claim by the landlord’s insurer against a tenant where there is not a written lease agreement? (Alberta, Canada)
Is there a resulting trust where a non-titled party has contributed directly or indirectly to the acquisition by the title holder of the property or the improvement of such property? (Alberta, Canada)
Can an insurer recover against a third party for property damage caused by the insured? (Alberta, Canada)
When a testator begins a matrimonial property action against his ex-wife for his undivided interest in their jointly owned duplex home, does the testator have a right to dispose of the property at the time he wrote the will? (Alberta, Canada)
In what circumstances will a spouse who is not a spouse be able to claim an interest in her partner's property? (Alberta, Canada)
In what circumstances will an insurer be able to proceed with a statement of claim for a motor vehicle accident due to the length of the claimant's claim? (Alberta, Canada)
Can a specific performance claim by the Respondent be a viable claim? (Alberta, Canada)
What is the impact of subrogated interests on personal injury and property damage claims? (Alberta, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.