In a motor vehicle accident case, is a plaintiff entitled to a "crumbling skull" analysis?

British Columbia, Canada


The following excerpt is from Lewis v Gibson, 2018 BCSC 1713 (CanLII):

The use of the phrase "crumbling skull" to describe a plaintiff's condition is, in any event, rarely helpful. As Major J. explained in Athey v. Leonati, there are no special rules or analyses that apply to claims made by plaintiffs who, before becoming victims of a tort, are affected by conditions that may deteriorate in the future. Damages are always to be assessed by reference to the situation that the plaintiff would be in but for the wrongdoing. Describing a plaintiff as coming within the "crumbling skull doctrine" does not eliminate the need for a complete analysis of the pain and suffering caused by the accident.

The judge found that there was "an inter-relationship between the pain that the plaintiff experienced from her physical injuries and her emotional or psychological problems". He also found that her psychological problems "worsened because of the accident". Even in cases where a plaintiff is suffering from serious chronic depression, an aggravation of the symptoms attributable to a tort is compensable: Sangha v. Chen, 2013 BCCA 267. In the present case, where the plaintiff's symptoms were fairly minor before the accident, but developed into major depression as a result of the accident, it is clear that damages ought to have been awarded. …

Other Questions


What is the "crumbling skull rule" applied to a plaintiff in a motor vehicle accident case? (British Columbia, Canada)
Is there any case law that supports the argument that a plaintiff was entitled to a higher income than he would have if he had not been injured in a motor vehicle accident? (British Columbia, Canada)
What is the entitlement of a plaintiff in a motor vehicle accident case? (British Columbia, Canada)
In a motor vehicle accident case, is there any case law where a wife who was a passenger in the vehicle was found to have been driving at the time of the collision? (British Columbia, Canada)
Is a plaintiff entitled to an award for costs of future care for a plaintiff who was injured in a motor vehicle accident? (British Columbia, Canada)
In a motor vehicle accident case, is a plaintiff entitled to an assessment that is not punitive or punitive and is not based on sentimentality? (British Columbia, Canada)
Does the "crumbling skull" principle affect the quantum of damages awarded in a motor vehicle accident case? (British Columbia, Canada)
What is the test for a “crumbling skull” plaintiff in a motor vehicle accident? (British Columbia, Canada)
If a plaintiff has a crumbling skull, does the crumbling skull rule entitle her to additional damages? (British Columbia, Canada)
In a motor vehicle accident case, is a plaintiff entitled to an annual loss of income from his after tax income as a result of his personal expenses? (British Columbia, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.